Thursday, August 14, 2008

The Politics of Change

Every election time, politicians come around with very sweet sounding rhetoric. Traditionally the world over, it has been the same script of ‘ better roads, better schools, water for everyone, higher standards of living, affordable healthcare’ and so forth. I recently listened to Barack Obama talking about broken bridges across the United States that need fixing using the money that so inexplicably goes to Iraq. It is the name of the game.

Necessitated by the uniformity of these messages, some clever politicians introduced sufficiently ambiguous rhetoric; things like promising to bring back a sense of national pride, bringing people together and all that kind of crap. Woven into this discussion is the notion of change too (the kind that you can believe in, see or even Xerox. Some talk of change that is real).

People like fantasy and that is why this kind of rhetoric works like a magic pill.

Bill Clinton, easily one of the greatest presidents of the United States, used this argument of change to turn the tables against a sitting President who only months before the election was enjoying an unprecedented 90% approval rating, a President who was fresh from leading the country into sweet victory in the first gulf war. He gave hitherto unheard-off promises like allowing gays and lesbians in the military (something that turned out to be a gross mistake). His promise of a ‘new different America’ was pure charm.

Did he live up to his promise? Well, it depends on how you want took at it. One thing we all agree on is that no President had received a blowjob in the oval office before. That’s definitely change.

The 21st century face of change is of course Barack. He has done stuff no one would have ever imagined and this is all attributable to the same argument of change. We cannot pass judgment on him because he is yet to be elected, but a look at those being touted as likely cabinet members in an Obama administration points to another gimmick in the making. People that served in previous administrations continue to be the nerve centre of his campaign. At what point Bill Burton underwent a complete makeover, nobody knows. Bill Richardson and John Edwards, the same old politicians will supposedly help Obama deliver change to Americans. On that one, time will tell.

Back home, we have been treated to this gimmickry as well.

On 12th December last year, President Mwai Kibaki promised Kenyans what he called a “clean-hands” government. That is definitely high sounding. But this is a President who had been in power for five years. This is a President who had flatly refused to stand up for principle and tell economic criminals like Prof. George Saitoti that there was no room for people with questionable backgrounds in his cabinet. Some would have read betrayal in that, but then again it would have sent a clear message about a President truly committed to a different order, a new order. He did it again this year and he will do it again.

Then there is the face of change in Kenyan politics, Raila Amolo Odinga. I will not talk about his very well documented personal involvement in crime and duplicity, but I will talk about his team members. Hon Raila calls himself “an agent of change”. Let us look at some of his fellow ‘agents of change’;

Otieno Kajwang, a man whose name was stricken off the list of Advocates of the high court for petty crime, is Raila Odinga’s idea of a perfect immigration minister, after all the waragi he took at Makerere, just like conning legal clients, did not stand on his way to prominence!

Henry Kosgey, the man credited with bringing down the Kenya National Assurance through out-of-control embezzlement of funds is the man to bring industrial change to Kenyans. William Ruto, Dalmas Otieno, William ole Ntimama and the other guys would, after all, be there to lend support. They have actually shown a very concerted commitment towards this end over the years.

Then there is my party leader, Hon Kalonzo. During the Presidential debate that never was (he is the only candidate that showed up), he said this in response to a question; “……and this is going to come in the form of real change”. That made me cringe. Sir, did you not serve a backward regime for ten years?
I love you, man, but please don’t lie to me.

It is all about change that never was, change that will never be. It is all pandering!

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

I really dont understand why you have such high expectations of politicians? The sleaziest scum to ever roam the earth? And their incentive is clear--to get elected. For that, they will say and sometimes do, anything (look at all the hate speech in the 07 campaigns).

My problem is with the electorate. Of course, we'll all buy into the change being preached, elect the scumbug, then he wont perform, then we'll want change, then he'll speak about change, spicing it up with some fear, hate,and ethnic chauvinism, then we'll elect him back again. End of.

I know that is an abstraction, but it does a good job of generalizing our experience in vicious self-flagellation, for half a century or so.

But there might be hope. The signals sent in the past elections (if for a moment you block out the violence and hate), for anyone who cares to look, were not entirely bad. A fair bunch of players were replaced and some new kids brought into the block. Some local dailies may have printed the stats for that. The less-than-$2aday-electorate might be in the process of waking up, of gathering information, and making decisions based on that information, at least at more localized levels. The high ranking leadership has been unassailable. A time may come when the poor of Kenya will, in the end, change more than the name of their master.

Anonymous said...

Vikii,
one couldn't have put it better. ALL politicians excel in one thing: lying. The masses everywhere want change that will improve their lives. Clever politicians come around with nonsensical phrases like 'You are the Change we've been waiting for' and crowds are like 'YES, WE CAN'. Trust me, I really want Obama to win. But I think he is made from the same genetic political DNA like his ilk.

As for our three goons, they don't stop with lies; they go ahead and engage in economic crimes.

Anonymous said...

Vikii, a belated welcome too.

Anonymous said...

vikii, surprise surprise, never thought you could ever see a blemish on your man. good article

Bado said...

Henrik Ibsen, in an Enemy of the People, asserts that the masses are idiots. All that masses want, therefore, is someone to herd them, in any direction. Idiots can buy into any argument. For some reason, the word 'Change' seems to strike a central chord in the limited cognition of idiots. That is why conniving politicians always throw it at us. Again and again! And we always embrace it.

Nice post

Anonymous said...

My man, BO doesn't lie. He is gonna bring really change in Washington DC. He won't forget us either. Change is coming to KENYA! i feel sorry for you pessimists who believe otherwise

UrXlnc said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
UrXlnc said...

vikii you covered a lot of ground with this post and touched on various issues. hard to comment without writing a book.

i absolutely hear you when you say politicians can be quite crafty with insidious proclamations.

but lets reflect first on change. no doubt we are all aware of the truth in the saying that "in life the only consistent fact is that change happens" and there are many ways to say this

http://www.clemmer.net/books/pdf/GTD_Chapter1.pdf

so whether we like it or not, we are actually looking for leaders who will work with us and help us all manage change (in our personal, community and national endeavors) better. the retrogressives are in fact those who want to remain where they were before.

for some communities the mere act of electing a different leader is in fact change enough (e.g kibaki 2002, but of course he just went back to the old ways of doing things but with different faces, what a dissapointment so i agree many politicians just cant deliver on their promises)

however, irrespective of the checkered pasts and misdeeds of many leaders, there are a good number of people who can deliver on their promises and we must first determine and set the agendas for change (and its management) then continuously strive to find such people to lead the efforts (tainted pasts or not).

about those tainted pasts of our current crop of leaders, i usually prefer to cut them some slack because under kenyatta and moi, dissent often had grave consequences and the very few who braved it are either long gone or physically scarred. but in the period 2002 to present due to the galant efforts of 2nd liberation fighters RAO, Ngilu, Wamalwa, Kiraitu, Gitobu, Muite, Kibwana, Shikuku and whole long list of such fellows there has been a lot more freedoms and a lot more choices so am not as willing to be as forgiving.

you do raise a lot of good points bro.

Vikii said...

Hakujakucha, thanks too for having me over.

b-carotene, yeah, the problem is the electorate. We write such kind of articles expecting them to be read not by the politicians, but by the electorate--u and me. The essence is to have people understand that all that glitters is not gold. That politicians will sugar coat their words to make us think they have tickets to heaven. So we are basically calling upon people to be on the look-out for these 'conmen'.

Urxlnc,I am actually one of those who dont think that we owe anybody the presidency, a cabinet post, a parliamentary seat or any other position just because they fought for some liberation. All I can tell them is 'many thanks' but when choosing my leaders, I will go for the one that I think is best qualified. What my point is, especially about Hon Kalonzo Musyoka,he should promise everything else but not radical change. This is for the simple reason that he still has very nice words about Moi. Now if he wants to talk about personal integrity, I will be there to acknowledge that because I quite honestly believe he stands above the rest in that regard.

But more important, Urxlnc, is the need for us as a country to be prepared to recruit political leaders from outside the current pool. It is just a pity that the Obama phenomenon would have been impossible in Kenya. I am just hoping for the day when somebody like Paul Tergat would just announce his entry into politics and the whole country rises with him. Now I know it will happen---in my dreams!

Anonymous said...

the good thing vikii

is that through forums such as this, we are helping shape the electorate as well as values or expectations for our leaders.

we are slowly getting there.

am sure its not lost on you that despite our differences in criteria of actual choice of candidate, our expectations on what they should do are the same or similar across the board.

very soon time (age) permitting some from these forums will be presenting themselves and i hope we'll be able to identify with them.

UrXlnc

Anonymous said...

to clarify above

some of us (like me) are fast approaching our "sell by" dates but i hope there are many in the "coming soon/next attraction" category

UrXlnc

Vikii said...

How old are you, dude?

Anonymous said...

hahaha vikii

you know i dont approve guys posting resume to re-inforce weak arguments.

iyo acha ikae

UrXlnc

Anonymous said...

guys, u dry or what? give us a new post! or tell us if you closed shop.