Tuesday, August 12, 2008

The ODM's Concept of Democracy

My understanding of true democracy tells me that people should be given a free will to elect their leaders and in the event that their choices lose, then they should concede defeat, congratulate and embrace the winner and respect the choice of their opponents. Losing graciously not only earns you respect, it gets you more admiration.

Like I have said elsewhere, no one can really tell who won last year’s polls. That election was pretty much a split decision and it actually doesn’t make a lot of sense dwelling on it. This uncertainty has been compounded by the seeming incompetence of the Electoral Commission and the security forces.

Now because this is about grace and civility, I will not rub it upon the disciples of the ODM that they lost, or at least that some evidence suggests they did so fair and square. That, I will pass for now. I will, however, point out that the chief embarrassment was how they reacted to the announcement of the results by the body that is solely constitutionally mandated to announce the results.

The usual way of handling conflicts is through the discourse of the court. No one should buy the crap that the compromised nature of our court system stopped them from seeking justice there because this same party filed the highest number of parliamentary petitions by any one single party in the history of our multi-party electoral politics. Considering the ODM gave the handling of the parliamentary and local authority elections a clean bill of health, this high number of petitions not only points to a party acutely reluctant to concede defeat, it also shows an inexplicable level of double standards. No wonder they are doing absolutely nothing to bring sanity to the courts if they truly believe the courts dance to the whims of the executive. They are not only occupying a central position in government, they also control the legislature. Why the lull?

Come the by-elections. When the PNU coalition lost the Wajir seat against all reasonable expectations, their candidate hugged and congratulated the winner. He promised to do everything he could to help the elected opponent in his bid to make the constituency better. PNU and its partners, of course performed dismally in Emuhaya and Ainamoi and they accepted the verdict of the voter. The ODM’s reaction to the losses in Embakasi and Kipkelion, on the other hand, was not surprising. Their Embakasi candidate declared herself the winner and then proceeded to court. Kipkelion was blamed on negative ethnicity as if this was not ODM’s prime principle—as if this is not what keeps the party going.

Yesterday, we were treated to the same old defeatist antics once again. The same party marauders who stopped the tallying of votes in Kamukunji in December were at it again trying to intimidate everybody. The returning officer and the winning candidate were called all kinds of names. People threatened violence and were it not for the heavy police presence, there would have been serious bloodshed.

Which brings me to the questions; when are this party and its omnipotent caudillo ever going to lose a fair contest? When are they ever going to acknowledge the rationale behind competitive politics? Are they ever going to learn to respect the fact that their opponents can also get the better of them? Are they willing to upgrade their understanding of democracy?

My conclusion which is in actual fact a belief I have always held is that the ODM does not defend its members; it preys on their ignorance and vulnerability. It does not stand for democracy; it perverts democracy. It desires not to free its members from political bondage; it desires to imprison its members within its own fascist, unorthodox and utterly misplaced conception of democracy.

But then again, even Machiavelli would have appreciated all this!

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

'that the PNU does not defend its members; it preys on their ignorance and vulnerability. It does not stand for democracy; it perverts democracy. It desires not to free its members from political bondage; it desires to imprison its members within its own fascist, unorthodox and utterly misplaced conception of democracy'

Just replaced ODM with PNU above, and one would thing you were roasting PANUA. I am not trying to defend ODM, but I want to tell you that your arguments would wash ONLY if Kenya was a democracy. The political system we have in Kenya is called a democracy for lack of the real word. You assert for example that we do not know who won the presidential elections - in true democracies, people would have a re-run. I do not belief in political parties in Kenya. Parties come and go. PANUA hasn't even celebrated its first anniversary.

What I hate is the fact that we have the same goons playing musical chairs with parties perennially. I can't stand Kalonzo. Kibaki makes me feel like throwing up. Mr Molasses, well, he is entertaining. I am waiting for him to jump ship when he is tired with the DULY ELECTED mongrel.

Anonymous said...

Anon: 11.14, i agree with you. i'm against the idea of setting all the politicians on fire. we have to make do with the lesser devil and meander through our young developing democracy until some day we get a leader. I don't give a fig about parties either. Today we'll sing ODM or PNU and tomorrow, the same same players will teach us a different song. All the parties are trash at best. I would lay a wager on HE Raila A. Odinga to move our country forward. The thief should just do us a favour and drop dead like Mwanawasa.

Anonymous said...

Excellent post Vikii!!!
There were all those ODMorons howling they want their their rights and in the same breath flinging a helpless baby into a fire or putting a panga the 'enemy's' neck. That's as close as you'll get to democracy with the Morons. Violence and total irresponsibility. Dont hold your breath.
Let's march onwards with Dr. Steven. Forget about the thugs.

Anonymous said...

b-carotene,
i hate violence whether ODM or PNU instigated. But who is the good Dr you refer to? is it Kalooser by any chance? i thought Kenyans roundly rejected him?

Anonymous said...

vikii

i would agree that our politics (PNU, ODM, ODM-K) lacks the finese or decorum that we would hope for, and it doesnt matter the origin of discontent it quickly degenerates into shouting matches or near ridiculous showdowns which can turn tragic. i am howver not quick to point a finger at any particular aggressor or "victim" because this plays out equally.

i however wish to point to you the "excuses" for this rather (ir)rational or irksome behaviour which incidentally you state yourself or allude to.

first a preamble or rambling

although not necessary, but certainly a gracious winner, will inspire (or shame) a loser to graciously concede defeat. the converse, hyper amped gloating will naturally lead to sore losers. but like i said this is neither here nor there and certainly no excuse for ruckus

the real "excuse" (debatable of course) is that concede defeat, a loser and his/her supporters must necessarily experience a feeling that the process has been conducted freely and fairly within the prevailing circumstances adn any real or imagined threat or perception that the process is/was not above board creates room for discontent. politicians by definition will amplify any such opportunity.

vikii your closing statement of the 2nd para reads

"This uncertainty has been compounded by the seeming incompetence of the Electoral Commission..."

which brings back to light the very thorny issue (and evidently you appear to agree with) that the process could be a little or seriously flawed due to minor or gross incompetence. we have no way of determining these without a determined forensic audit, in which case we can only go by whichever side we support.

i would however not feel compeled to make sweeping statements like "concept of democracy" due to tallying/vote count. as an ODM supporter, i know the overal democratic process in kenya is working well, propaganda and counter-propaganda, campaigns and other process are proceeding very well sometimes with glitches but little executive strong arm tactics or muzzling. our problem is and still remains the credibility of ECK and i would support any PNU, ODM or ODM-K intiative to clean that house up including heckling their officers and micro managing their processes.

on the other hand, our personal definition of graceful losing is no different from beauty lying in the eye of the beholder and i therefore cannot in a democratic society force my way of doing or reactign to situations on anyone else so long as no laws are broken and at least nominal standards of decency are practiced.

UrXlnc

Kwale said...

Vikii, you are my hero!
Arguably the best writer in Kenya, no-one can put it better than you have just done there. My question though is, why don't you post it in Kumekucha, they need to read this! Or why don't you become a column writer in one of our national newspapers? Kenyans need to hear this, especially the already brainwashed ODMmreamers.

Excellent post Keep it up!

Anonymous said...

'dr' jones:
Dr. Steve is currently the Vice President. He's destined for bigger things and will be a robust competitor for the highest office in the land come the next generals, whenever that will be.
This time the rug wont be pulled from under his feet by some crafty operatives as it was last time.
Wont it be nice to have a non-confrontational, decent, presentable, articulate doctorate holding fort? Indeed, a remarkable first.

Vikii said...

Urxlnc, I agree. There is a clear lack of decorum across the political parties. Primitivism appears to be the sole definition of our politics.

But I have a question for you; what is your take about the reaction of the ODM after they lost Kamukunji? Don't you think they have accumulated such an astonishing series of cries after every electoral loss? Don't you think there is a level of unwarranted complaints that is ridiculous? In other words, do you agree with Anyang Nyong'o that the PNU should have surrendered the seat to the ODM, just like they should have surrendered the Presidency and the Embakasi one? I don't know, man, but some of this mediocrity is laughable.

b-carotene, thanks. I appreciate it.

Kwale, thank you. I used to be one of the contributors at Kumekucha, but they dropped the axe on me. I respect them, however. I appreciate the work they are trying to do there and that is why I still blog there. Now, do I agree with them? Hell no.
About being a columnist with one of our dailies, well, I am flattered. We will definitely explore that possibility when the time is ripe. Thanks for the nice words, bro.

Anonymous said...

vikii

whether there was real foul play or not, sometimes it just makes better sense to accept a verdict and leave it at that.

I have no idea what top ODM officials expected with that Kamukunji results whether it was tallying or voting exercise as long as it was with current ECK, there would be problems. for that matter any other event involving ECK as currently consituted is always going to be a problem. ODM either have to use parliament to force a change in ECK or live with it. Including accepting (flawed or true) results and outcomes. We cannot continue having this situation with crying wolf all the time.

And BTW despite our differences in opinion/perspective, i like your writing style, good work

UrXlnc

Vikii said...

Thanks urxlnc. The difference in opinion is what necessitates a discussion. It is why we blog; so we know what the other feels.

About the ECK, I actually think they are not all that bad. I mean they have given verdicts where not a single person raised a finger. My opinion is that the ECK is not the problem (Look at what is happening at City Hall now. The ECK is not involved). Now do we need to reform the institution as a matter of principle? Oh yeah. This should be captured in our review of the constitution. I was thinking of doing a post on the very loud silence the proponents of a new constitution have come to potray. I think we have been duped once again.

I am glad you like how I write. I like your work too, I sure do.